Discussion:
Bug#1063610: python3-binwalk: transition from p7zip to 7zip
Add Reply
c***@allfreemail.net
2024-02-09 20:50:01 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Package: python3-binwalk
Severity: normal

Dear Maintainer,

your package Depends/Recommends/Suggests or has some other relation to the p7zip/p7zip-full/p7zip-rar packages, which have become transitional packages in debian trixie and will eventually be removed from debian. They have been replaced by 7zip and 7zip-rar packages.

If necessary, please modify your package to use the executables from the 7zip package instead. If everything everything behaves as expected, then remove p7zip/p7zip-full/p7zip-rar from the control file and replace it with 7zip and/or 7zip-rar.

This bug is currently filed with normal priority but the priority will be increased as the release date of debian trixie gets closer.

Thank you for maintaining software in debian.
c***@allfreemail.net
2025-03-02 22:30:01 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Source: binwalk
Version: 2.4.3+dfsg1-1
Followup-For: Bug #1063610
Control: severity -1 important

Dear Maintainer,

I emphasize the necessity of updating your package to eliminate the dependency
on the p7zip/p7zip-full/p7zip-rar packages, which are now transitional packages
in debian trixie. Debian project aims to minimize the use of transitional
packages and actively encourages the proactive removal of dependencies on them.

Furthermore, it is important to note that the p7zip packages were based on a
codebase from the year 2016, with no updates upstream since. On the other hand,
the 7zip packages are built on a more recent and actively maintained codebase,
both within debian and upstream. Given the significant changes that may have
occurred over the past 9 years, it is crucial to verify that your package still
functions as intended with 7zip as a dependency instead of p7zip.

We are approaching the various freeze stages of debian trixie, I am increasing
the severity of this issue as previously announced, to reflect its urgency.
Please take the necessary steps to update your package accordingly.

Thank you for your continued efforts in maintaining software in debian.
Loading...